Shi'as i have a few questions?

[lifton]

Why do you have your own version of the Ka'bah in iran?
Does that mean the one in Saudi Arabia that just so happened to be built by Ibrahim 'alayhis salam and his son, mean nothing to you?

Why do you people say Ya 'Ali, when that's clearly shirk? (associating partners with Allah) i thought you only call upon Allah 'azawajal?

Why do you reject the Sunnah of the Prophet Sal Allahu 'alayhi wasallam? Instead you follow a shaytan of a "sheikh".

Why do you slander the companions when you aren't even worth the dirt they walked on?

Why am I always called a "Wahabi" by your followers of your religion?
I hope you know that's a myth.


Last question: Why do you practise Mut'ah? Temporary marriage. How many of you don't know who your fathers are?

Please enlighten me.

[tanishia]

I am from Iranian Kurdistan. I actually fell into the trap of shiites and became shiite for a while, although I can remember I had always some doubt about mutah and infallibility.

"Why do you have your own version of the Ka'bah in iran?".. it's actually in Kerbala. Qom is in Iran, and that's where they learn their pagan faith. See, you know what shiites say, they say, you have to go to hajj for obligatory, but to Kerbala out of love... see they love Imam Hossayn RA more than they love Allah SWT, clear shirk, as they worship the creation of Allah SWT.

"Why do you people say Ya 'Ali".... shiites will tell you than Ali RA is a partner of Allah SWT with the same powers and authority.. however, the joke is on them, that is shirk again. ALLAH HAS NO PARTNERS.

"shaytan of a "sheikh"".... YES... if laymen shiite were exposed to the truth, shiaism would be over

"slander the companions " ----- hating the people who the Prophet SAWS loved is war against the Prophet SAWS and Islam.

"Wahabi" .... shiite propaganda to discredit Ahlus Sunnah

"Mut'ah".... The Prophet SAWS did not encourage divorce, why would he allow a nikah with the intention of divorce? Shiites are confused.


May Allah SWT burn the shiites in this life and the next. Ameen. Let it be so.

[ern]

I am from Iranian Kurdistan. I actually fell into the trap of shiites and became shiite for a while, although I can remember I had always some doubt about mutah and infallibility.

"Why do you have your own version of the Ka'bah in iran?".. it's actually in Kerbala. Qom is in Iran, and that's where they learn their pagan faith. See, you know what shiites say, they say, you have to go to hajj for obligatory, but to Kerbala out of love... see they love Imam Hossayn RA more than they love Allah SWT, clear shirk, as they worship the creation of Allah SWT.

"Why do you people say Ya 'Ali".... shiites will tell you than Ali RA is a partner of Allah SWT with the same powers and authority.. however, the joke is on them, that is shirk again. ALLAH HAS NO PARTNERS.

"shaytan of a "sheikh"".... YES... if laymen shiite were exposed to the truth, shiaism would be over

"slander the companions " ----- hating the people who the Prophet SAWS loved is war against the Prophet SAWS and Islam.

"Wahabi" .... shiite propaganda to discredit Ahlus Sunnah

"Mut'ah".... The Prophet SAWS did not encourage divorce, why would he allow a nikah with the intention of divorce? Shiites are confused.


May Allah SWT burn the shiites in this life and the next. Ameen. Let it be so.

there is a failure on the part of some Muslim faithfuls in addressing legitimate concerns that humans have. There are many practices which Islam doesn't advocate but are blindly adopted in the Muslim world. No doubt we need to have an honest discourse amongst ourselves (Muslims) and chart a new way forward. As a timeless message, Islam must and indeed is flexible enough to accommodate the ever-changing global landscape but it is up to Muslims rise up to the challenge and make known to the world what we have to offer.

[bernd]

You won't get an answer sister

[celeste]

Why do you have your own version of the Ka'bah in iran?
not true. shia pray to Kaaba in Saudi Arabia.

Why do you people say Ya 'Ali, when that's clearly shirk? (associating partners with Allah) i thought you only call upon Allah 'azawajal?
this is not shirk.
"call on the dead to help"
do you know about tawassul? it is in Koran in many verses. for example do you know what means the ??????? in verse:
??????????? ???????? ???????????? 5:35

?

please study about tawassul:
http://www.al-islam.org/encyclopedia/chapter6b/5.html
http://www.al-islam.org/mot/tawassul.htm
http://www.al-islam.org/encyclopedia/chapter6b/6.html

also they are not dead and sahaba also did this.

imams do not decide who goes to Heaven and Hell.
but one name of Imam Ali (sa) is abul-ghasim. a hadith from prophe says he is called in this name because Ali (sa) is who divides people at Judgement day. but not from himself, based on God and Koran. it is like a Judge in court who talk based on law. not based on his own wish.
knowing when some one die is not amazing. prophet predicted this for many. so prophet is God? having some knowledge not mean they are God.
between knowledge of human and of is unlimited grades of knowledge. who has knowledge more than usual is not God. God has absolute knowledge. Imams still do not know many things. although know many more than people.
truth is that Imams have knowledge of prophet. and not absolute knowledge of God.

please study:
http://www.al-islam.org/wahhabism
http://www.al-islam.org/new-analysis-wahhabi-doctrines/
http://www.al-islam.org/truthaboutshiah/


Why do you reject the Sunnah of the Prophet Sal Allahu 'alayhi wasallam? Instead you follow a shaytan of a "sheikh".
shia accept and follow sunnah of prophet. what it shaytan of saeikh?!!!


Why do you slander the companions when you aren't even worth the dirt they walked on?
they position of Caliphate is only selected by God. and they occupied this position and this cused their good deeds be destroyed. please read:
http://pastebin.com/4eGMQmWV

Why am I always called a "Wahabi" by your followers of your religion? wahhabi is extreamly anti shia.
please distinguish between sunni and extremist Wahhabi (Salafi)
Sunni Muslims are good to shia. look at Egypt Muslims. they are very similar and friendly with shia.
but Wahhabi love to kill shia. they believe who kill 10 shia will go to Heaven.
they believe if they bomb shia and themselves be killed with eat lunch with prophet in Heaven. their brain is completely washed and they are all hate of shia.
Wahhabi is wolf in cloth of ship.
bin laden Al-Qaeda Taliban all are Wahhabi.
Wahhabi is in fact supported by Israel and England to destroy Islam.
Ashura day keep the message of Hussein (sa) alive to reach all humans.
Husain (sa) wanted to send his message with his blood to all the world and to all the humans.
the message of Hussain is:
there is two different Kind of Islam.
the pure Islam of prophet and Islam of Yazid (Ummayids) who celebrated killing of Husain (sa) the Imam and real Caliph of their time.
Husain (sa) said:
with Yazid, Salam [bye] to Islam.

the only way of peace is to finish Wahhabism (based in Saudi Arabia and financially supported by Oil money of Saudi Royal Family. Royal family support them as blackmail to US support Saudi Royal family politically and militarily and guarantee survive of Saudi family Kingdom)

http://www.al-islam.org/wahhabism
http://www.al-islam.org/new-analysis-wahhabi-doctrines/
http://www.al-islam.org/truthaboutshiah/

I hope you know that's a myth.


Last question: Why do you practise Mut'ah? Temporary marriage. How many of you don't know who your fathers are?
according to shia ???? or Mut'ah means temporary marriage. shia Muslims believe according to one verse of Quran and saying of prophet temporarily marriage is allowed under especial terms.
shia believes according to the verse 4:24 of Koran (????? ?????????????? ???? ????????? ??????????? ???????????? ?????????) temporary marriage is allowed in Islam and the marriage described in this verse can not be usuall marriage. according to shia Islam Mut'ah has terms and is only for some especial situations and is much different of harlotry for example a woman who accept Mut'ah should have relation with only her husband and this type of marriage has many terms of usual marriage with few differences. also shia believes companions of prophet did it when they were in long travels and were alone. shia believes Mut'ah was allowed at time of prophet but Omar banned it.


Please enlighten me.