by cumhea » Thu Feb 06, 2014 6:03 pm
Yes, it IS abuse, according to the askville ?Report Abuse? function. It certainly would fall in the category ?insulting other participants.? Because this is a public forum, as far as I am concerned, for the benefit of the whole community, I believe a degree of ?self-policing? should be the goal. In other words, folks should think about the rules in polite society for public speech before they post something. Think of it this way?What if you emailed the comment to a co-worker? Or pinned it up on a public bulletin board at work? Thing is, it doesn?t really matter whether such a comment or question is made in jest or as slander; whether or not it?s meant in a spirit of fun, or an in-joke between two folks or something like that, it can be very, very easily misinterpreted by the rest of the folks who see it. It "lowers the tone" of the whole site, as far as I'm concerned. And while I think it is harassment, whether or not the Askville team would or CAN do anything about it, or whether reporting such behavior does any good, or whether reporting anyone gets folks to change behaviors? well, let?s just say those are questions that don?t seem to have consistent answers from the askville team. As far as I can tell, they're sort of playing the "police the school corridors" by ear, not trying to universally apply the rules--which says to me the rules aren't completely thought out. This brings me back to self-policing, of course. We?re also adults here, and such squabbles ought to be able to just die off, shouldn?t they? What?s WRONG with a level of armed detent? "I?ll leave YOU alone if you leave ME alone?" The problem seems to be the sheer attraction of being able to take an available potshot. There?s the target?wide open! WHAM!!! I certainly do understand the joy of being able to actually USE the perfect line when the verbal target is just HANGING THERE, seemingly asking for it... but it just keeps animosity going--it adds fuel to the fire. Here?s another aspect of the issue. To what degree should this be a problem in the larger scheme of things? What SHOULD the Askville Team?s priorities be? Personally, I?m irritated by the changes in the newbie policies FAR more than I am irritated by personality clashes between Askvillers! I am by nature a peaceable person, and tend to just roll my eyes and go on about my business, regardless. I don't like squabbling, so I avoid it, and when the DB gets knee-deep in it, I don't go back. I enjoy this site, and I enjoy how I use it, and I plan to ignore and keep ignoring the bickering, and keep answering the questions that interest me, and keeping up with the DBs that interest me. While in an ideal on-line community, folks would refrain from such stuff, there's no such community. Drawing attention to negative behavior gives it attention, and I don't want to police other adults--so I follow my own advice: If such behavior bugs you, you can always go find another question or DB to visit, or re-ask the question to get those who were seriously interested in the discussion to continue. Early in my time here, an Askviller was loading down DBs with long non-pertinent quotes from songs, rather than discussion. There was no way I could see to stop the behavior--since polite requests and less than polite requests and reporting abusive behavior didn't work. So I removed myself. As far as I know, this person may still be doing it--but I won't know about it and won't let it affect me. Sources: Personal opinion. NancyE's Recommendations Teasing and Harrassment: The Frames and Scripts Approach for Teachers and Parents Amazon List Price: $9.95 Used from: $0.55 Blue Streak:: Swearing, Free Speech, and Sexual Harrassment Amazon List Price: $23.00 Used from: $0.01 Average Customer Rating: 4.0 out of 5(based on 1 reviews) I admit there are moments I want to yell what I used to yell at my kids when they were both young teens. "YOU"re BOTH AT FAULT HERE, SO JUST AGREE TO LEAVE EACH OTHER ALONE!" NancyE 69 months ago Please sign in to give a compliment. Please verify your account to give a compliment. Please sign in to send a message. Please verify your account to send a message.