That's ridiculous! I had a similiar problem when looking for dresses with my maids. I found one that was everything I was looking for, was at a great price, and looked unbelievable on everyone! My MOH of course "hated" the dress but everyone else is crazy for them.
She told me multiple times that since she's MOH, she should be wearing her own dress... not the same one as everyone else. I stood my ground (I think she just wanted to stand out.. it's how she is) and thankfully she didn't back out on me.
Good for you for sticking to your guns! You've done nothing unreasonable here!

